For the past few days, a meme featuring Pope Francis has gone viral. By using four pictures on Twitter, three of which are usually static, you can show the pope holding up anything you want instead of a communion wafer.
October 30th.
He will save us. pic.twitter.com/aZHizEjVZb
— President Warren G Haunting (@PopeAwesomeXIII) October 16, 2020
So I found the original image used in that Pope meme, and — unsurprisingly — he's holding the most holy item of all in it. #N64 pic.twitter.com/sqVqQkZ63h
— N64 Today (@N64Today) October 17, 2020
— ᴋʏʟᴇ ᴄᴏᴜʟᴛᴇʀ (@KyleCoulterVids) October 16, 2020
— Jacob Oller (@JacobOller) October 16, 2020
— Rachel Wolfson (@wolfiecomedy) October 16, 2020
i'm so fed up with that pope meme pic.twitter.com/y16bdCNujo
— muscle skoals (@MuscleSkoals) October 17, 2020
Some Catholics, however, are very unhappy with all of you for this blasphemy. Sister Theresa Aletheia, a death-obsessed nun, said all of these tweets were disrespectful.
The pope meme is not funny. If you’re Catholic (or anyone who desires to have a modicum of respect for someone else’s deeply held religious beliefs) don’t tweet or retweet it.
— Sr. Theresa Aletheia ☠️ (@pursuedbytruth) October 18, 2020
Another writer, Simcha Fisher, said the memes were “hurting Catholics.”
There's a meme circulating with Pope Francis holding up an object with his eyes closed, and people are shopping in various funny objects. In the original photo, the object is a host being consecrated. This means being turned from bread into the actual body and blood of God. 1/
— (((Simcha Fisher))) (@SimchaFisher) October 17, 2020
3/ I suppose people think it's fine to mock Catholicism because pedo priests + other various grave scandals. Please understand that, when you mock the sacrament of the Eucharist, all you're doing is hurting Catholics who have already been profoundly hurt by these same scandals.
— (((Simcha Fisher))) (@SimchaFisher) October 17, 2020
It’s safe to say many of the people enjoying the meme are religious themselves and see this as good fun, not social commentary on the Church itself, much else an indictment of Catholicism. None of the critics have said what aspects of the Church people are allowed to poke fun at. If the expression on the pope’s face is off limits, then what’s within the boundaries? And how is this the dealbreaker for you?
Some critics are making that point very bluntly:
the Pope once compared me, and people like me, to nuclear bombs, unfavorably
when your religious beliefs not only cast me as subhuman but shape the culture to enforce that belief, your beliefs are fair fucking game https://t.co/SINCHOmWFq
— Serenity “Nightmare” Dee (@sapphixy) October 18, 2020
sorry but when your religion interferes with people's lives they automatically get fair game to do whatever they want with any piece of it https://t.co/sZv3vFxTrG
— Norasferatu � (@NoraReed) October 18, 2020
oh no the catholic church is having their religious beliefs disrespected thank god they've never done that to anyone https://t.co/7NYNAWaiUz
— S-cara Poss-esten (@caraesten) October 18, 2020
If you can’t make sense of a joke involving one of the most famous people on the planet, you’re in no position to tell people what is and isn’t funny. Considering all the damage the Church has caused over the years, let people have this meme. It’s the least you can do.