Angry atheists are as old as atheism itself, but nowadays atheists are happy, un-angry, unperturbed, calm, cool, collected, Apollonian.

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Angry atheism is as old as atheism. It’s as old as theism itself.

Let’s imagine that thirty thousand years ago, one of our bent-over prehistoric ancestors, with grunts and flailing gestures, motioned to the sky as if gods were in residence there. And surely some surly prehistoric irreligious dissident raised an immediate hue and cry.

To the fragment of humanity who are the chronically incredulous minority (at this moment, or at any moment before), an improbable super-natural claim can kindle a flash of temper. “Why would you jump to that conclusion?” the incredulous person asks. It’s as if the rules of a pinball-like logic cry ’tilt’ the moment a supernatural explanation is introduced, because, after all, the natural explanation seems to serve.

For instance, at some moment in remote antiquity an anonymous proto-scientist stepped up to say a god in a horse-drawn chariot was pulling the sun across the daytime sky. And all but a small minority believed this, and they believed it for thousands of years. That kind of credulity irks the chronically incredulous minority and can turn them into angry people.

Anger in atheists is understandable. But how do we explain the happy atheists we meet nowadays?

Another related source of anger in atheists comes from their claim to know what the majority does not know. Imagine that you were among the minority in ancient Greece who knew the pantheon of gods did not exist, that all the temples and temple sacrifices were for nothing at all, that Zeus was a fiction, that Demeter was the deification of corn and Dionysus of wine. Or imagine that you were among the small group who disbelieved the Norse pantheon, or the ghosts of Kyoto, or the angels of Medina.

Though your disbelief would have been kept prudently secret, the very magnitude of the majority’s error, and the fact that you could not publicly dissent without social penalty, might very well have made you angry.

Yet another source of anger for religious doubters is that they could have been raised with religious belief and left belief behind later in life, feeling duped in the process and experiencing anger at the institutions that fooled and miseducated them in the first place.

Anger in atheists is understandable. But how to explain happy atheists we meet nowadays?

3 reasons why happy atheists exist today

1. Happy atheists have learned that, when it comes to religion, only a minority can be right, and atheists are comfortable in considering themselves the correct minority. In their view, why shouldn’t they be as certain as a Buddha or a Mahavira or a Jesus or a Muhammad or a Nanak about truth?

There are so many, many religions. But the members of any one religion are out-numbered by the members of all the other religions combined, so that any single religion is a minority position in the wide world. Christianity is the largest single religion, but most people are not Christians because only two billion people of eight billion people are Christian. Most people are not Hindus. Most people are not Muslims. Most people are not Jains. And most people are not atheists.  And on, and on, and on. Whoever is right about religion, they are of necessity in the minority, and the majority is living a delusion. Un-angry atheists serenely accept that they are the unerring minority.

2. Many atheists were never indoctrinated into religion as children and never participated in religion at all throughout their whole lives, and thus they feel no particular animus toward religion, no anger, no venom, because religion never hurt them or duped them. They may even be indifferent to religion.

3. In the West, atheists may consider that they are ‘winning.’ There has been a multi-century evolution in secularizing Western societies and minimizing the importance of religion. For a thousand years, almost all the intellectuals of Europe were believers in God, but in the last 150 years, the Western intellectual class has become mostly non-religious, atheist, or agnostic. Church attendance in Europe has plummeted regularly for 100+ years, and this downward decline never reverses itself from year to year. A few of the old European churches have been re-purposed into books stores, oriental rug stores, Italian restaurants, and homes for eccentric millionaires. In the U.S.A., current high school students are the least religious teenagers in the history of the country, and the ‘nones’ (religiously unaffiliated) are as numerous as Catholics and Baptists now. These data bring peace of mind to atheists, dispelling anger.

We are all familiar with the model of the angry atheist. But now we espy atheists who are happy, unperturbed, calm, cool, collected, Apollonian, un-angry, and accepting of their singular, non-menacing, un-minatory minority position.

J. H. McKenna (Ph.D.) has taught the history of religius ideas since 1992 at various colleges and since 1999 at the University of California, where he has won teaching awards. He has published in academic...

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments