This example had to be pointed out to me. I missed it. It’s subtle.
Okay, so preamble. Imagine a young British sprinter, John Smith, suddenly explodes onto the world circuit from nowhere. The country hasn’t really heard of him, the world certainly hasn’t. He wins an Olympic gold from nowhere. In their first front-page splash in a national newspaper, the headline reads “Dreams really come true!” and below, the large tagline reads, “John, 18, wins Olympic gold”. So you introduce this elite athlete to your readership as “John”.
That would be weird. There would be no reason for doing this.
So explain this:
As you may or may not know, our good friend Emma
Raducanu has just won the US Open at 18. Remarkable for a host of reasons (randomly picked up from the BBC):
Emma Raducanu at the 2021 US Open: Nine matches played, zero sets lost.
She has lost just 27 games in total across her SIX main draw matches in her first overseas Grand Slam.
Emma Raducanu is the first British female Grand Slam finalist since Virginia Wade in 1977.
She’s also the first British woman to reach the US Open final since Wade in 1968.
And she is just the fourth British woman to reach a Grand Slam final in the Open era.
Emma Raducanu is the first qualifier to reach a Grand Slam women’s singles final in the Open Era.
Ranked 336th in the world before Wimbledon, Emma Raducanu is now knocking on the door of the world top 30.
I watched it – it was superb.What makes things awkward for the Daily Mail (DM) is that she is an immigrant, brought to the UK at two, and is a Mandarin-speaking child of Romanian and Chinese parents. Her surname is the very Romanian name “Raducanu”. What a heady mix for the DM. They love Romanians, usually. Don’t they?
“Huffington Post: British media demonized Romanians but spared Bulgarians” is an article that looks at reporting of Romanians in the UK right-wing media landscape.
And there have been these, many targeting Romanians explicitly:
And this rarity of a step back:
Can’t say they are big fans of the Chinese either. I could dig up some lovely examples in that context, but you get the point.
Now, I don’t want to have a big immigration debate. Uncontrolled immigration can be an issue, and we have problems with perception vs reality. But the double standards and subtle techniques of the right-wing media don’t go unnoticed by some astute people.
Turns out The Daily Express were at it first, including some rather egregious double standards:
Good ole Emma
Raducanu, she’s like our best mate now. Hey, Emma! Nice one! What a lovely name you have. Just like a Jane Austen character. Lovely English name, that.
Now I don’t want to weaponise Emma Raducanu in the culture wars, but we should not ignore instances of casual racism when we see them.
Stay in touch! Like A Tippling Philosopher on Facebook:
Please support by sharing or donating, or both! You can buy me a cuppa. Or buy some of my awesome ATP merchandise! Please… It justifies my continuing to do this!